Throwback Cafe Menu

116 Outwater Ln, Garfield, NJ 07026, United States
$$$ Cafe
(75 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to **Throwback Cafe**, a hidden gem in Garfield, NJ that whisks you back to the classic diner experience. With a varied menu that boasts hearty sandwiches and delightful milkshakes, this cafe is a must-visit.

  • The Heart Attack: A mouthwatering medley of bacon, sausage, Taylor ham, egg, and cheese, it's a satisfying start to your day at just $13.00.
  • The Gobbler, featuring hot turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato, is another fan favorite, also priced at $13.00.
  • For something sweet, indulge in the Chunky Monkey with peanut butter, banana, and jelly for just $6.50.
  • Drink options include revitalizing iced coffees and refreshing juices, all reasonably priced.

Reviews highlight the warm atmosphere and friendly service, making Throwback Cafe a top spot for regular visits. Don't miss this unique blend of nostalgia and flavor!

Breakfast

  • Meat, Egg & Cheese

    Choice of bacon, sausage, ham, Taylor ham, turkey, or turkey bacon with egg and cheese served on a round roll, bagel, or croissant.

    US$10.50
  • Breakfast Wrap/Quesadilla

    Eggs, cheese, and your choice of breakfast meat.

    US$10.40
  • Build Your Omelet
    US$15.50
  • Bread & Spread

    Bagel, roll, or croissant with your choice of spread.

    US$5.50

Burgers

  • Classic Burgers

    Cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion (add bacon optional).

    US$15.50
  • Triple Melt Burgers

    American, cheddar, Swiss, ketchup.

    US$15.50
  • Smooth Operator Burgers

    Mozzarella, avocado, special sauce.

    US$15.50
  • Smokey Campfire Burgers

    Bacon, onion, BBQ sauce.

    US$15.50
  • Crunch Burgers

    American cheese, potato chips, special sauce.

    US$15.50
  • Pacific Rim Burgers

    Teriyaki glaze, Swiss, grilled onions, avocado.

    US$15.50

Specials

  • The Heart Attack

    Bacon, sausage, Taylor ham, egg, and cheese.

    US$13.00
  • The Gobbler

    Hot turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.

    US$13.00
  • The Chunky Monkey

    Peanut butter, banana, jelly.

    US$6.50
  • Chicken 1-Up Melt

    Grilled chicken breast, mozzarella, tomato, balsamic drizzle.

    US$13.50
  • Hot Honey Cruncher

    Grilled chicken, cheddar, potato chips, finished with a drizzle of hot honey.

    US$13.50
  • PB&J Burger

    Beef burger topped with peanut butter, bacon, and a layer of jelly.

    US$15.50

Wraps & Quesadillas

  • Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheese, ranch or balsamic dressing.

    US$13.50
  • Turkey Club

    Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheese, mayo.

    US$13.50
  • Cheese Quesadilla

    Grilled tortilla filled with melted cheese.

    US$13.50
  • Chicken Quesadilla
    US$13.50

Sandwiches & Melts

  • Tuna Melt

    Tuna, tomato, melted Swiss.

    US$13.50
  • Grilled Chicken Melt

    Chicken, mozzarella, roasted peppers, toasted.

    US$13.50
  • Chicken & Cheddar Ranch

    Grilled chicken, cheddar, ranch dressing.

    US$13.50
  • Spicy Chicken Melt

    Grilled chicken, pepper jack, jalapeños, chipotle mayo.

    US$13.50
  • Taylor Ham & Cheese

    Jersey classic, pork roll with your choice of cheese.

    US$13.50

Drink Menu

  • Coffee
  • Iced Coffee - One Size (20 Oz)
    US$5.50
  • Refreshers
    US$5.50
  • Poland Spring Water
    US$1.50
  • Apple Juice
    US$2.00
  • Orange Juice
    US$2.00
  • Can Of Soda
  • Alkaline Water
    US$2.50
  • Celsius
  • Coconut Juice
    US$4.00
  • Mystic
    US$4.00
  • Snapple
  • Gatorade
    US$4.00
  • Soda 20 Oz
    US$4.00
  • Monster Energy Drink
    US$5.50
  • Red Bull
    US$5.50

Blender Bar

  • Harvest Greens
  • Superfruit All Stars
  • Tropical Harmony
  • Blooming Berry
  • Aloha Pineapple
  • Mellow Mango
  • Peach
  • Strawberry
  • Milkshake

    Ice Cream + Milk

    US$9.50

Candy

  • Kit Kat
    US$2.50
  • Snickers
    US$2.50
  • Rice Crispies
    US$2.50
  • Reeses
    US$2.50
  • Oreos
    US$2.50
  • Kinder Bueno
    US$2.50
  • Granola Bar
    US$2.50
  • Extra Gum
    US$2.50